Explainer

Targeted Programs

Advancing DEI Initiative

Targeted programs are initiatives reserved for members of marginalized or underrepresented groups. Examples include:

  • Scholarships 

  • Grants

  • Fellowships

  • Internships

  • Mentorship and sponsorship programs

  • Coaching programs.

Many of the lawsuits in our tracker are challenging targeted programs, arguing that they violate anti-discrimination laws by excluding members of certain demographic groups based on race, sex, or other legally protected characteristics. For example, one lawsuit (which has since settled) challenged an internship program offered by the National Museum of the American Latino that limited eligibility to Latina, Latino, and Latinx students.

Organizations that have identified an unacceptably high legal risk in a targeted program may wish to consider one of the following shifts:

  • From cohorts to content. Instead of limiting eligibility to certain demographic cohorts, consider opening the program to candidates of any background who demonstrate a commitment to the content of the program. 

  • From cohorts to character. Instead of selecting applicants based on having a particular identity, ask applicants to respond to a prompt describing how race or other aspects of their identity have affected their life, “be it through discrimination, inspiration, or otherwise.” This formulation was permitted by the Supreme Court in the Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard case, provided an applicant is assessed on their experiences or attributes as an individual, not on the basis of their group identity.